Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream : The Ultimate Packed With Protein

This Ninja Creami protein ice cream wasn’t just a treat : it was an absolute lifesaver this summer.

It all started during peak chaos: hot July afternoons, school pickup meltdowns, and blog drafts written with one eye open at midnight. One day, after chasing my toddler through a backyard sprinkler obstacle course, I stood at the freezer craving something cold, comforting, and not loaded with sugar.

I had seen the Ninja Creami machine all over my social media feed and decided it was finally time to make something for myself. I got my favorite vanilla protein powder, some almond milk, and a spoonful of creamy peanut butter. I froze the mixture, gave it a spin, and when I took that first bite, I was absolutely blown away.

Game changer.
It was nothing short of divine. Every spoonful was creamy, sweet, and utterly satisfying. Unlike my old, chalky protein shakes, this actually felt like a genuine dessert. That single pint of Ninja Creami protein ice cream quickly became my personal reward. Now, I make a fresh batch every single week.

Whether it’s a healthy bedtime snack or post-leg-day fuel, this ice cream is everything.

Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream: My Go-To Healthy Frozen Fix

---

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

• Author: Victoria
• Total Time: 24 hrs freeze, 5 min prep
• Yield: 1 pint

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

This Ninja Creami protein ice cream is a high-protein, low-sugar frozen treat that tastes like real ice cream with only a few simple ingredients.

---

Ingredients

1 scoop protein powder

½ cup almond milk

½ banana

1 tbsp sugar-free maple syrup

¼ tsp vanilla extract

Pinch sea salt

Optional mix-ins: cocoa, fruit, nut butter

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

---

Instructions

1. Blend or stir all ingredients until smooth.

2. Pour into Creami container up to max fill line.

3. Freeze flat for 24 hours.

4. Spin on Lite Ice Cream mode.

5. If needed, Re-Spin.

6. Optional: Add mix-ins and use Mix-In mode.

7. Serve and enjoy!

Notes

Use ripe banana for natural sweetness.

Re-spin the next day if re-frozen.

Add 1 tbsp milk if it’s too crumbly after first spin.

• Prep Time: 5 mins
• Category: Dessert
• Method: Ninja Creami
• Cuisine: American

Why You’ll Love This Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream

This isn’t your average, bland protein shake frozen into a sad, icy block of disappointment. This recipe stands out because it’s a genuinely delicious and incredibly creamy treat that you’ll actually look forward to. It completely transforms your protein intake into a truly rewarding, dessert-like experience.

• Ultra Creamy Texture: The Ninja Creami transforms a simple protein mix into scoopable magic.
• Customizable Flavors: Whether you’re craving chocolate, vanilla chai, or blueberry matcha, it’s easy to tweak.
• Protein-Packed & Macro-Friendly: Each serving packs 20g+ of protein with minimal sugar.
• With a carefully selected combination of quality ingredients, this recipe eliminates that dreaded, strange aftertaste. It delivers a genuinely delicious and satisfying flavor with every single scoop.
• Crafting your own Ninja Creami creations is an incredibly budget-friendly way to enjoy a delicious treat. By simply using a few pantry staples, you can completely bypass those overpriced, store-bought pints and make something just as decadent—and often even better.

Plus, if you loved our Strawberry Sorbet Ninja Creami or Cottage Cheese Protein Brownies, this creamy treat is right up your alley.

Whether you’re hitting the gym hard, chasing little ones, or just want a treat that loves you back—this Ninja Creami protein ice cream will be your new freezer favorite.

🥶 How to Make Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream

🥄 Ingredients You’ll Need

This recipe is creamy, customizable, and macro-friendly. Here’s what I keep stocked for my go-to base:

• 1 scoop vanilla or chocolate protein powder (whey or plant-based)
• ½ cup unsweetened almond milk (or milk of choice)
• ½ banana (for creaminess)
• Feel free to add a tablespoon of sugar-free maple syrup or honey for a touch of sweetness, adjusting the amount to your personal taste.
• ¼ tsp vanilla extract
• Pinch of sea salt
• Optional: 1 tbsp nut butter, cocoa powder, or fruit mix-ins

Tip: If you’re looking for a fruity twist, check out my Peach Sorbet Ninja Creami or Banana Cinnamon Creami for flavor inspiration!

🔁 Ingredient Substitutions

Make it your own with these flexible swaps:

⚙️ Tools & Equipment

You don’t need much, but these are essential for that creamy texture:

• Ninja Creami machine
• Creami pint container (must freeze flat!)
• Small mixing bowl + spoon
• Blender (optional for smooth blending before freezing)

📋 Step-by-Step Instructions

Here’s exactly how I make this ice cream creamy—not chalky or icy!

1. Mix Ingredients
   In a bowl or a high-speed blender, combine the protein powder, milk, banana, your chosen sweetener, a dash of vanilla extract, and a pinch of salt. Mix or blend until the mixture is completely smooth and all the protein powder has been dissolved, with no clumps remaining.
2. Pour into Creami Pint
   Pour the mix into your Ninja Creami container up to the max fill line. Tap on counter to remove bubbles.
3. Freeze Flat (Important!)
   Now, place your pint in the freezer for at least 24 hours. Do not skip this step! Uneven freezing is the main reason you get a powdery texture on the first spin.
4. First Spin: “Lite Ice Cream” Mode
   After freezing, install the pint in the Ninja Creami and spin it once using the “Lite Ice Cream” function.
5. Assess the Texture
   After the first spin, if the mixture looks powdery or crumbly, that’s completely normal for protein blends. Just do a re-spin to achieve that smooth, creamy consistency.
6. Optional: Add Mix-Ins
   After the second spin, you can stir in your favorite additions like chopped fruit, chocolate chips, or a dollop of peanut butter. Then, use the “Mix-In” function to blend them evenly throughout the ice cream.

🧊 Storage Tips

• Store leftovers in the Creami container.
• Re-freeze and re-spin the next day for a fresh batch.
• If it’s too icy after storage, add 1 tbsp almond milk before re-spinning.

🍓 Serving Suggestions & Toppings

You can dress this up or keep it simple. Here’s how I serve mine:

• Fresh berries + almond slivers
• Drizzle of peanut butter + dark chocolate chips
• Toasted coconut + crushed protein cookies
• Top it like our Salted Miso Date Creami with a sweet-savory swirl

Pair it with a post-dinner scroll through our Blueberry Maple Matcha Creami—your freezer will thank you.

🧮 Nutrition Info (Per Serving)

⚙️ Mastering the Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream Process

After patiently waiting for your pint to become completely solid in the freezer, the next step is where the real magic happens. This crucial stage is all about leveraging the right settings, mastering smart techniques, and skillfully avoiding that dreaded, powdery texture that can ruin the whole experience.

The initial spin is the most critical part of the process. You’ll take your rock-solid, frozen pint and lock it securely into the Ninja Creami machine. At this point, the machine will likely encounter a very hard block of ice, and that’s exactly what it’s designed for. This is where you select the appropriate setting—either “Lite Ice Cream,” “Creami,” or a similar function on your specific model. The machine will then get to work, shaving the frozen base into a fine, granular powder.

Don’t be alarmed when you open it up and find what looks like a powdery, dry mess. This is a common point of panic for many first-time users, but it’s a completely normal part of the process.

This texture means the machine has done its job of breaking down the frozen block. Now, you’ll add a small amount of liquid—a splash of almond milk or a bit of water—and re-spin the mixture. This re-spin is the key to transforming that powdery base into the velvety smooth, creamy consistency that the Ninja Creami is famous for. The added liquid helps hydrate the fine particles, allowing the machine to work its magic and create that perfectly scoopable, dessert-like texture. This two-step process is what separates a successful pint from a disappointing one and is the secret to achieving a truly perfect, decadent result every single time.

🌀 Best Ninja Creami Settings for Protein Ice Cream

What Mode to Use:

For protein-based mixes, the “Lite Ice Cream” mode works best. Here’s why:

• It’s gentler than “Ice Cream” mode, perfect for protein-based mixes that lack fat
• It creates a fluffier, more scoopable consistency
• It preserves delicate add-ins like fruit or nuts

Pro Tip: After the first spin, always check the texture. If it’s dry or crumbly, hit the Re-Spin button. This usually does the trick.

Should You Ever Use “Ice Cream” Mode?

When it comes to selecting your spin setting, there are a few general rules to follow. If your base contains a higher amount of fat—from ingredients like peanut butter, full-fat yogurt, or heavy cream—you can often use the standard “Ice Cream” mode. This setting is designed for richer, denser ingredients.

However, if your base is low in fat and sugar, it’s best to start with “Lite Ice Cream.” This is the go-to setting for most protein-based or fruit-heavy recipes. When in doubt, always begin with the “Lite Ice Cream” function to ensure a perfectly smooth and creamy result without over-processing.

If you’re just starting with Ninja Creami protein recipes, my Protein Powder Ninja Creami Guide has more setting breakdowns by texture and mix-in type.

📋 Step-by-Step: From Frozen Block to Creamy Scoop

Here’s how I ensure that silky texture every single time:

1. Freeze Flat for 24 Hours
   Your base must freeze evenly. Uneven freezing leads to uneven spinning = chalky ice cream.
2. Spin on “Lite Ice Cream”
   Once fully frozen, insert into the Creami and spin on Lite Ice Cream mode. This is your first check.
3. Check the Texture
   Open the lid—does it look powdery or sandy? That’s common with protein bases.
4. Re-Spin If Needed
   Hit the Re-Spin button. In most cases, this creates the perfect texture on the second go.
5. Add Mix-ins (Optional)
   Want to stir in berries, nuts, or chocolate? Create a hole in the center, drop in your mix-ins, and use the “Mix-In” mode.
6. Serve Immediately
   Ninja Creami treats are best served fresh. But if you re-freeze, you can always re-spin later with a splash of milk.

Trouble with dry or powdery ice cream? Try adding 1 tbsp of almond milk before re-spinning. Works like a charm!

Looking for more flavor adventures? Our Mug Protein Mousse Recipe is another creamy, high-protein dessert you can whip up in minutes—no freezing required!

❄️ How to Store & Serve Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream

You’ve mastered the spin, but that’s just the beginning. Now, let’s talk about how to store your creations and dress them up to achieve those serious, dessert-worthy vibes. These are the final, crucial steps that will transform your simple pint into a masterpiece.

🧊 Storage Tips & Make-Ahead Tricks

Yes, you can re-freeze it—here’s how to keep it scoopable.

• Store Right in the Creami Container
  After enjoying your first scoops, simply smooth the top and place the lid back on. Freeze flat again.
• Re-Spin Before Serving Again
  On Day 2, don’t expect soft serve straight out of the freezer. Re-spin it using “Lite Ice Cream” mode with 1 tablespoon milk added to refresh the texture.
• Avoid Refreezing Mix-Ins
  If you’ve added things like nuts or chocolate chips, they can get weird when re-spun. Save those for the final mix-in step after your last spin.
• Make Multiple Flavors Ahead
  I batch 3–4 pints in advance—vanilla, chocolate peanut butter, and matcha coconut are my favorites!

Looking to expand your frozen flavor game? The Lemon Sorbet Ninja Creami is ultra-refreshing and great for fruity Ninja Creami protein ice cream hybrids.

🍨 Serving Suggestions & Topping Ideas

Here’s where you can turn this healthy dessert into a seriously satisfying treat.

Want to add even more nutrition and indulgence? Try layering scoops with the Blueberry Maple Matcha Creami for a two-tone protein sundae. It’s as pretty as it is delicious.

📊 Quick Nutrition Recap (Per 1 Pint)

These numbers will vary slightly depending on your protein powder and mix-ins. Always check your macros if tracking closely.

❤️ Conclusion:

So there you have it—the Ninja Creami protein ice cream recipe I make on repeat. It’s a fast, flexible, and wonderfully delicious treat that feels like the ultimate reward, especially after a tough workout or a late night of hard work. This isn’t just a recipe; it’s a testament to the idea that you don’t have to sacrifice flavor for fitness.

Whether you’re new to the Ninja Creami or already a dedicated fan, this recipe is guaranteed to become a new favorite. It’s a game-changer, turning a chore into a craving and making your healthy habits feel like a luxury. If you give it a spin, don’t hesitate to share your amazing creations with me—I would absolutely love to see what you come up with!

📌 Follow me on Pinterest and Facebook for more healthy indulgence → You’ll find more Ninja Creami flavors, family-friendly desserts, and protein-packed ideas the whole household will love and thank you .

FAQs: Protein Ice Cream with the Ninja Creami: